With internet voting, theres a single piece of software that can be controlled. How estonias evoting system could be the future forbes. The idea of having internet voting in estonia gained popularity in 2001. In 2014, researchers at the university of michigan conducted a study that identified major risks in the security of estonias internet voting system and recommended its immediate. No such wholesale redesign of the internet or hardwaresoftware has occurred since the serve. Once all the information is verified, they have the voting options. This has very little to do with sharing software and everything to do with. In 20 free software foundation europe criticized partial publishing of the source code of evoting system and for using nonsoftware licenses for. Estonia has offered online voting for more than a decade with great success and some unique security twists that could alleviate many of the concerns raised. Nov 22, 2018 today, estonia, with its population of 1.
Internet voting, or i voting, is a system that allows voters to cast their ballots from any internet connected computer anywhere in the world. Voters voting over the internet were required to insert their pin and answer two personal questions. Researchers identify security risks in estonias online. Internet voting or as it is called in estonia, ivoting is available in the country from the tenth to the fourth day prior to election day. Within the group of internet voting system users, four core countries have been using internet voting over the course of several electionsreferenda.
In estonias system citizens can vote from the comfort of their own homes, including from abroad while traveling. For additional materials and contact information, visit. It happened after a sovietera statue was relocated, and hit media outlets, banks and government bodies. Free, the free software foundations evoting software before concluding that internet voting was too risky to be used for elections of any importance. Using an opensource edition of the voting software. People have had the option to vote online for 10 years, and like in brazil, they introduced it gradually, starting with trials at municipal elections and expanding from there.
One chapter describes the internet voting used in estonia. Thats because estonia is the world leader in electronic voting. Homomorphic tallying for the estonian internet voting system arnis parsovs1,2 1software technology and applications competence centre, estonia 2university of tartu, institute of computer science, estonia august 3, 2016 abstract in this paper we study the feasibility of using homomorphic tallying in the estonian internet voting system. Jul 17, 2017 with internet voting, theres a single piece of software that can be controlled. Jan 03, 2018 online voting has become a norm in estonia and it is now more secure than ever. In chapter 6, dylan clarke, an erc research fellow at newcastle university, and tarvi martens, the chief architect of the estonian remote internet voting system, describe the estonian internet voting system. An independent assessment of the procedural components of the. Estonian prime minister andrus ansip trying out the new system of internet voting in tallinn as he casts his ballot from his office computer on. Worlds most hightech voting system to get new hacking. Updates with plan to shorten evoting in sixth paragraph. Smartmatic electronic voting system and software duration. Executive summary independent report on evoting in estonia. Estonian internet voting software used in utah republican caucus.
Alex halderman university of michigan, ann arbor, mi, u. The team performed a security evaluation of estonia s internet based e voting system estonia is the only country in the world that relies on internet voting in a significant way for legallybinding national. In recent polls, 2025% of voters cast their ballots. Security analysis of the estonian internet voting system. Worlds most hightech voting system to get new hacking defenses. Their system requires a usb card reader, but there is a smartphonebased app in the works. Estonias opensource voting is the future of democracy estonia publicly posted its code for online voting last week. Estonias internet voting system has such serious security vulnerabilities that an international team of independent experts recommends that it should be immediately discontinued, researchers. The dangers of internet voting the heritage foundation. In september 2010, the district of columbia unveiled an internet voting pilot project, called digital vote by mail, which was designed to allow military and overseas voters to download blank and return completed ballots over the internet, and invited the scientific community to test the systems integrity prior to its actual use. To vote in estonia, one simply visits the national election website and downloads and installs the voting application. Security analysis of estonias internet voting system duration.
The research question that this thesis aims to answer is does internet voting in estonia affect voter turnout. A few countries, like estonia, have gone for internetbased voting in national elections in a big way, and many others like ireland and canada have experimented with it. Nov 04, 2014 estonian prime minister andrus ansip trying out the new system of internet voting in tallinn as he casts his ballot from his office computer on october 10, 2005. Whats more, estonia has a proportional representation voting system, rather than a. Back in 2005, estonia became the first nation to hold a legally binding general election over the internet something that has now become a norm, while most countries are still only contemplating the possibility. The report also recommended that maintenance of the internet voting system during the entire internet voting process be prohibited. Now estonia teaches the world a lesson in electronic. By 2009, estonia had advanced the farthest in utilizing internet voting technology. In estonia, each voter has a national id card that they use to identify each citizen. Completely unrelated to the electronic voting systems used elsewhere, which involve costly and problematic machinery, the estonian solution is simple, elegant and secure. Estonia is probably the only country in the world where 99% of the public services are available online 247. Report on the estonian internet voting system verified voting. The idea of having electronic voting in estonia gained popularity in 2001 with the eminded.
Estonia has implemented internet voting in national elections since 2005 and the percentage of voters voting via internet has trended up in each successive election. In 2005, estonia became the first country in the world to hold nationwide elections using this method, and in 2007, it made headlines as the first country to use ivoting in parliamentary elections. The economist explains how did estonia become a leader. In 2007 it became the first country to allow online voting in a general election. This is because estonian law requires all ballots to be destroyed within a month of the election. Estoniandeveloped internet voting software was used in the utah republican caucus where the utah republicans voted to choose the partys nominee for president in the 2016 election. Estonia, the only country in the world where voters elect their leaders through online balloting, is taking steps to fend off potential hacking attacks as cybersecurity fears intensify. Jun 07, 2017 estonia has offered online voting for more than a decade with great success and some unique security twists that could alleviate many of the concerns raised by last years us presidential election. Then you insert your national identity card into your computers card reader. The card is a regular and mandatory national identity document as well as a smart card allowing for both secure remote authentication and legally binding digital signatures by using the estonian state supported public key infrastructure. Either of these would be an attractive target for statelevel.
Estonia, which created the worlds first nationwide internetbased voting system, has finally released its source code to the public in an attempt to assuage a longstanding concern by critics. Since then, legally binding internet voting has been applied by various other. Mar 01, 2019 estonias internet voting system blindly trusts the election servers and the voters computers, halderman said in 2014. Homomorphic tallying for the estonian internet voting system. This system aimed to take advantage of the numerous benefits of online voting e.
Back in 2005, estonia became the first nation to hold a legally binding general election over the internet something that has become a norm now, while most countries are still only contemplating the possibility. In this months estonian parliamentary elections, a whopping 44 percent of the ballot was cast using evoting. For americans, with a presidential election approaching later this year, its a timely issue. The purpose of this letter is to present concerns regarding the estonian internet voting system, and to offer suggestions on alleviating these concerns. Using an opensource edition of the voting software, the researchers approximated a version of. An independent assessment of the procedural components. Online voting has become a norm in estonia and it is now more secure than ever.
Internet voting estonian cyber security news aggregator. Apr 14, 2016 estoniandeveloped internet voting software was used in the utah republican caucus where the utah republicans voted to choose the partys nominee for president in the 2016 election. Open letter on freedom and internet voting to estonias national electoral committee. The term power voting or e voting can refer to both fixed voting locations as in voting booths and remote as in over the internet electronic voting, in order to reduce the confusion between the two the electronic voting in estonia is called i voting. The team performed a security evaluation of estonias internetbased evoting system.
Security analysis of the estonian internet voting system j. Estonia publishes its evoting source code on github ars. Jul, 20 estonia, which created the worlds first nationwide internetbased voting system, has finally released its source code to the public in an attempt to assuage a longstanding concern by critics. Once the voting application is downloaded, the software. Open letter on freedom and internet voting to estonias. The estonian parliamentary election in 2007 also used internet voting, another world first. Despite the admonitions of experts, online voting is emerging in several u. Either of these would be an attractive target for statelevel attackers.
May 10, 2019 estonia implemented the eus first countrywide internet voting ivoting system in 2005. Security analysis of estonia s internet voting system duration. Estonia s internet voting system has such serious security vulnerabilities that an international team of independent experts recommends that it should be immediately discontinued, researchers. Its government is virtual, borderless, blockchained, and secure. Two years later, a denialofservice cyberattack targeted both private and public sector websites. In theory and practice, why internetbased voting is a bad. Internet voting, or ivoting, is a system that allows voters to cast their ballots from any internetconnected computer anywhere in the world. Estonia became the first nation to hold legally binding general elections over the internet for the municipal elections in 2005.
In this months estonian parliamentary elections, a whopping 44 percent of the ballot was cast using e voting. Security analysis of the estonian internet voting system drew springall travis finkenauer zakir durumeric jason kitcat harri hursti margaret macalpine j. Unlike the electronic voting machines used in the us, estonias system is. People have had the option to vote online for 10 years, and like in brazil, they introduced it gradually, starting with.
Kitcat helped found the open rights group and served as its evoting coordinator. He led 25 election observers in monitoring evoting and ecounting across the 2007 english. Internet voting in estonia national democratic institute. Whats more, estonia has a proportional representation voting system, rather than a winnertakeall system. May 16, 2014 estonia is the only country in the world that relies on internet voting in a significant way for national elections. The system is currently used for estonia s national parliamentary elections, municipal elections and is planned to be used for the may 2014 european parliamentary elections. In 2005, estonia became the first country in the world to hold nationwide elections using this method, and in 2007, it made headlines as the first country to use i voting in parliamentary elections.
Estonian electronic voting system vulnerable to attacks. Estonia held two elections in 2019, with the general election on march 3. Now estonia teaches the world a lesson in electronic elections. Estonia is the only country in the world that relies on internet voting in a significant way for legallybinding national elections in recent polls, 2025% of voters cast their ballots online. The system is currently used for estonias national parliamentary elections, municipal elections and is planned to be used for the may 2014 european parliamentary elections. In this months estonian parliamentary elections, a whopping 44 percent of the ballot. Estonia s internet voting system blindly trusts the election servers and the voters computers, halderman said in 2014.
About 14 countries have used some form of online voting, but estonia was the first to introduce permanent national internet voting. The team chose to analyze the estonian system because estonia has one of the highest rates of internet voting participation in the worldover 21. Does internet voting in estonia affect voter turnout. Several papers have examined the use of new voting techniques, for instance postal voting and electronic voting, to enable voting and potentially affect voter participation. Estonias internet voting system blindly trusts the election servers and the voters computers, halderman said in 2014.
Tallinn, estonia in the plush seats of a fireplacewarmed hotel cafe here, over a steaming cup of green tea, veljo haamer opened up his laptop computer. Report on the estonian internet voting system verified. A few countries, like estonia, have gone for internet based voting in national elections in a big way, and many others like ireland and canada have experimented with it. Estonia is the only country to offer internet voting to the entire electorate. Governments can respond to electionrelated cyber threats in a way that embraces technology and creates a system which commands public trust. At the caucus, the voters had the opportunity to vote using traditional methods or to vote online. Implemented in 2005, estonias internet voting ivoting system now serves as a model for governments on how online voting can be done. Mar 02, 2020 estonias opensource voting is the future of democracy estonia publicly posted its code for online voting last week. Log analysis of estonian internet voting 20 2015 sven heiberg 1 arnis parsovs 23 jan willemson 24 1 smartmaticcybernetica centre of excellence for internet voting 2 software echnologyt and applications competence centre 3 university of artu,t institute of computer science 4 cybernetica november 5, 2015 1. The estonian internet voting system builds on the estonian id card.
910 101 1363 1587 1594 1159 1260 1541 244 515 24 1028 126 1455 1209 415 1024 1616 1195 466 317 370 568 402 1208 611 52 531 1314 783 1379 972 537 420 1082 186 1290 353 341 669